Here are mine, though all are tough choices:
EP: Senor & the Queen (2008)
Song: Say I Won't (Recognize)
Reason: Great dance song, and I like this: "so come on before we get much older, and that can happen any one of these nights."
Album: Sink or Swim (2007)
Song: We Came to Dance
Reason: Excellent music, great dance song. Love this part: "Never break their hearts never make em cry so come on, Strike up the band with a song that everybody knows, If I'm not your kind then don't tell a soul."
Album: The '59 Sound (2008)
Song: Film Noir
Reason: Like the opening, and the lyrics throughout.
Album: American Slang (2010)
Song: American Slang
Reason: Tough choice, excellent lyrics, and great opening.
Album: Handwritten (2012)
Reason: Love the lyrics.
Edit: John, did you go the Gaslight concert on Monday? I talked to Scott and he said he was going. How was it? Who all went?